The club's lack of success in the national competition was mirrored in the county competition, its appareances in the Renfrewshire Cup normally ending with a heavy defeat. Lochwinnoch's best performance came in 1888–89, beating Johnstone Rangers 2–1 away in the first round,[5] drawing a bye in the second, and only losing to Morton 4–2 in the third.[6] It was a significant improvement, given the club had lost 12–0 to Morton in the first round in 1886,[7] but it could not be sustained as professionalism in the game grew.
However, the club did have success at district level, winning the Johnstone & District Cup in its first entry in 1887–88. Lochwinnoch beat Johnstone Harp 1–0 in the final, thanks to a superior passing game.[8] The club also won the Charity Cup - a trophy donated by the Johnstone Rangers club for clubs in Johnstone - the same year.[9]
The last record of the club is of its withdrawal from the 1898–99 Scottish Qualifying Cup, having been drawn to face Thornliebank.[10]
Colours
The club is known to have worn the following colours: